1 Jan There has been a recent upsurge in interest in Buddhist philosophy, but there is as yet no satisfactory text on the subject. Buddhism as. Buddhism as Philosophy has ratings and 21 reviews. the gift said: this is a book i have had for years, i read now, in chapter reads a day each, but n. In this clear, concise account, Siderits makes the Buddhist tradition accessible to a Western audience, offering generous selections from the canonical Buddhist.
|Published (Last):||4 June 2016|
|PDF File Size:||19.13 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||1.89 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Perception is impermanent – 4: The idea behind Buddhist ethics is threefold: I’d pair it with a classic text book on analytic philosophy e.
The book runs aground when it covers the various schools of Siderits buddhism as philosophy. The Abhidharma goes on to discuss dharmas parts that do not disappear under analysis—i. I am sure I will be returning to this text to re-read. Feb 23, Matt rated it liked it. And Siderits buddhism as philosophy weaves his narrative around these texts with keen insight and admirable organization.
I was especially thrilled to read in more detail the Buddha’s proposals for moderation in life and one way in which the idea of Nirvana can be interpreted. Buddhism as Philosophy, by Mark Siderits. Students of philosophy will find much to ponder in these pages, as Siderits does a great job of situating Buddhist philosophical concerns historically, and compares to western philosophical traditions, showing the similarities and perhaps more importantly, where Buddhist philosophers took different tacks.
I got the feeling that a lot of the concepts being presented were written in an overly complex manner. Whilst the above extract may appear to be more history lesson than philosophy, it siderits buddhism as philosophy an important example of the background information that Siderits supplies throughout the book, and which give the reader important insights into the contexts of Buddhist philosophy. Maybe it was beyond me. I had many of the questions, pitfalls, and misunderstandings he mentions in the siderits buddhism as philosophy buddhism chapters and these definitely had an impact on me.
The response to these objections includes the idea that dreams are impressions that exhibit a lot of the same properties as reality. This is the famous karma.
It siderits buddhism as philosophy a lot of things left murky by ‘Introduction to Buddhism’ books which do, on the other hand, go into the colorful bits about the multiple hells and Gautama’s encounters with divinities and so onand also brought out very important background assumptions for classical Indian philosophy as a whole to my shame, I siderits buddhism as philosophy no idea, for instance, that non-reflexivity–the knife cannot cut itself; the eye cannot see itself; the mind cannot think itself –was just a shared assumption that wasn’t thought to require argument.
They even claim that dharmas are conceptual fictions.
Also recommended is Nonduality siderits buddhism as philosophy David Loy for a more comparative approach. Trivia About Buddhism as Philo Feb 08, Billie Pritchett rated it liked it Shelves: Impressions-Only and the Denial of Physical Objects. This book does more than just report what Buddhist philosophers said; it presents the arguments of the Buddhist philosophers, in their own words, and it invites the reader to assess their overall cogency.
Jan 27, Lin Kudla rated it it was ok Shelves: Jan Westerhoff – – Journal of Indian Philosophy 36 4: Buddhist practitioners would siderits buddhism as philosophy themselves a favor by reading this as well, as it provides just that respectful questioning so rarely seen within the Buddhist sanghas. Buddhism as Philosophy fills that void.
Nov 09, Evan Micheals rated it did not like it.
Buddhism as Philosophy: An Introduction by Mark Siderits
Paperbackpages. Ellis – siderits buddhism as philosophy Lulu. And these ideas received their first philosophical formulation, in the work of Madhyamaka’s founder Nagarjuna, in about the mid-second century CE.
To be honest, I enjoyed the first fourth or fifth of this book. An Introduction to Buddhist Ethics: Adrian Konik – – Brill. Consciousness is impermanent – 6: This is illustrated on the following extract where Siderits is investigating the relationship between suffering and the Buddhist teaching of not-self.
Buddhism as Philosophy: An Introduction
Of course, eiderits many a Buddhist practitioner this whole endeavor may smack of intellectual folly, for they will feel that it is in the walking of the Buddhist path that it is to be evaluated rather than siderirs arguments formulated for and against its central doctrines.
I sometimes dislike and seek to change volition – 5: Colorblinds might disagree about the color of a thing, but they will be a tiny majority. Still gets three stars because the first half of the book dealing with early Buddhist philosophy was very clear siderits buddhism as philosophy the siderits buddhism as philosophy book contained long excerpts from sutras and commentaries.
Various arguments are given at this point This philosophical approach to the issues is systematically applied by the buddhisk, and he uses logic to examine Buddhist ideas that normally are less rigorously explored in most works on the subject.
Newer Post Older Post Home. The chapters also have excellent references for siderits buddhism as philosophy reading. What makes such a vast majority of sideritx agree on colors? I would not recommend reading this book For the right person, I can’t recommend this book highly enough!! I sometimes dislike and seek to change consciousness – 6: The Abhidharma metaphysics also talk about the various dharmas of water, air, fire, and earth.
See All Goodreads Deals…. I sometimes dislike and seek to change feeling – 3: Unlike other texts that serve to introduce Buddhist thought, siderits buddhism as philosophy is written by a philosopher and it shows how the Buddhist tradition deals Taking the three main philosophical areas of philosophy, ethics, metaphysics and epistemology as his framework, he describes the major developments in Buddhist thought, covering those found in early Buddhism and subsequent schools slderits Mahayana Buddhism.
With that said, I siderits buddhism as philosophy not hesitate to point somebody less familiar than myself in the direction of this handy book. The Sanskrit word skandhas refers to the five aggregates that the Buddha said comprised the person.